StarCentral’s Verdict On Ice Cream Man: Is It Worth Your Time and Money??

Eli Roth serves up a gleefully ridiculous horror ride that knows exactly what it is — and has absolutely no interest in behaving itself

There is a particular kind of horror film that doesn’t want to frighten you into silence. It wants you to laugh, wince, yell at the screen and occasionally wonder whether the filmmakers have completely lost their minds.

Ice Cream Man is very much that movie.

Directed by Eli Roth, the latest horror offering is the cinematic equivalent of being handed an ice-cream cone, taking one innocent lick and discovering there is something horribly wrong with the flavour. It is colourful, nasty, deliberately ridiculous and unapologetically excessive — and if you walk into it expecting a serious, grounded horror experience, you may find yourself wondering what on earth you’ve just bought a ticket to.

But if you embrace it as a gloriously unhinged B-horror movie?

Well, that’s where the fun begins.

DON’T TAKE IT TOO SERIOUSLY

Much of the criticism surrounding Ice Cream Man appears to centre on its absurdity. It’s unrealistic. The dialogue can be ridiculous. The characters aren’t exactly Shakespearean. The story occasionally seems to be held together with little more than blood, ice cream and sheer determination.

And honestly?

That’s part of the appeal.

This isn’t trying to be Hereditary. It isn’t attempting to reinvent psychological horror or deliver a carefully constructed meditation on the human condition.

It’s a horror playground.

The best way to approach Ice Cream Man is almost like playing a particularly deranged horror video game. You move from one outrageous scenario to another, waiting to discover what grotesque surprise is lurking around the next corner.

One moment you’re following the story.

The next, you’re watching an increasingly ridiculous kill unfold and thinking, Surely they aren’t actually going to do this.

Then they do.

That unpredictability keeps the film moving at a brisk pace, and there’s very little danger of boredom.

And, frankly, that’s worth something.

A LOVE LETTER TO B-MOVIE HORROR

The film wears its affection for old-school B-horror proudly.

There is a wonderfully trashy, colourful quality to the whole production that recalls the gleefully excessive horror films of the 1980s. The Stuff is an obvious influence, particularly in the way Ice Cream Man takes something completely ordinary and turns it into something deeply unpleasant.

The result is candy-coloured nightmare fuel.

It’s cheesy.

It’s cartoonish.

It’s often completely bonkers.

And that’s precisely why it works.

There is something refreshing about a modern horror film that isn’t constantly trying to convince you how important it is. Ice Cream Man doesn’t seem particularly interested in prestige. It wants to entertain horror fans who came for blood, mayhem and outrageous kills.

Think less elevated horror and more Halloween Horror Nights attraction after dark.

The comparison is surprisingly fitting. The film has that same sense of moving from one outrageous horror set-piece to the next, with every sequence seemingly competing to outdo the previous one.

THE GORE IS THE MAIN EVENT

If you’re watching Ice Cream Man primarily for the kills, you’re unlikely to leave disappointed.

Eli Roth has never been known for restraint, and that philosophy remains firmly intact here.

The violence is graphic, nasty and often deliberately excessive. There is a gleeful sense of escalation to the carnage, with the film repeatedly asking just how far it can push its premise.

The practical effects are where the movie is at its strongest.

There’s something wonderfully tangible about seeing practical makeup, prosthetics and physical effects doing the heavy lifting. The violence has texture and weight, giving many of the kills a nasty physicality that can be missing from effects-heavy modern horror.

Not every effect is equally convincing, though.

Some of the digital work is noticeably weaker, and there are moments where the CGI pulls you out of the experience. The contrast is particularly obvious because the practical effects are often so much more effective.

When Ice Cream Man gets physical, it gets wonderfully disgusting.

When it goes digital, things can occasionally look a little cheaper.

It’s hardly a deal-breaker, but it’s noticeable.

THE STORY? DON’T OVERTHINK IT

The screenplay is probably going to be the biggest hurdle for some viewers.

There are moments when the dialogue ias so exaggerated that you can practically see the wink behind the camera. Characters say things that sound as though they were written specifically to provoke a reaction, while the film occasionally introduces strange pieces of lore without bothering to explain them properly.

But again, context matters.

If you’re looking for a tightly constructed horror screenplay with perfectly developed characters and carefully established mythology, this probably isn’t your flavour.

If you’re willing to accept the film as heightened, campy horror, the dialogue becomes part of the entertainment.

Some of the intentionally cheesy lines are genuinely funny.

Others simply leave you staring at the screen.

Either way, Ice Cream Man rarely feels dull.

And for a horror movie, being boring is arguably a much bigger sin.

THE CHARACTERS AREN’T THE POINT

Character development isn’t exactly the film’s priority.

The people populating this nightmare are primarily here to find themselves in increasingly terrible situations. This isn’t a character study where every person receives a beautifully constructed emotional arc.

They’re pieces on the horror chessboard.

That isn’t necessarily a criticism.

The film knows its priorities. It wants to create an atmosphere of escalating chaos, and the characters are there to move that chaos forward.

Some performances fit the intentionally exaggerated tone better than others, but expecting award-season acting from a film like this is rather like ordering a salad at an all-you-can-eat horror buffet.

You’re here for the blood.

THE AI CONTROVERSY

One of the more complicated conversations surrounding Ice Cream Man involves its use of artificial intelligence.

AI-generated material appears briefly in several sequences, particularly during the film’s dream-like imagery. Importantly, the actual footage is relatively limited and doesn’t dominate the movie.

That doesn’t mean the issue should simply be dismissed.

The use of generative AI in filmmaking remains a legitimate and increasingly important conversation, particularly when it involves artists, animators and visual-effects professionals whose work can potentially be replaced or bypassed by emerging technology.

Eli Roth has indicated that some of the imagery originated from hand-drawn artwork he created before being developed using AI tools. If that’s an accurate representation of the production process, there is a meaningful distinction between using AI as a tool to manipulate or animate an artist’s original work and generating material wholesale through AI.

The question of where that line should be drawn is worth discussing.

But within the context of the finished film, the AI material is brief enough that it doesn’t define the overall visual experience.

The practical effects, makeup and physical gore remain the real stars of the show.

NOT EVERYONE WILL LOVE IT

And that’s completely understandable.

Ice Cream Man is not a film that will magically win over people who dislike Eli Roth’s particular brand of horror.

If you find excessive gore tiring, campy dialogue irritating and ridiculous situations frustrating, there probably isn’t much here for you.

But if you enjoy B-grade horror, practical effects, outrageous kills and films that occasionally seem to ask, “What if we just went completely nuts?”, there’s a lot to enjoy.

The movie knows exactly what it is.

And more importantly, it doesn’t apologise for it.

THE VERDICT

Ice Cream Man isn’t a masterpiece.

It isn’t sophisticated.

It isn’t particularly realistic.

And it certainly isn’t interested in subtlety.

Thank goodness.

What it is, however, is fun.

It’s fast-moving, bloody, colourful, weird and frequently hilarious in its sheer commitment to excess. There are cheap-looking effects, uneven dialogue and a story that occasionally feels like it has wandered into the freezer and forgotten where it left the plot.

But there’s something charming about a movie that simply wants to have a good time.

The horror landscape has become increasingly crowded with films determined to be profound, socially significant or psychologically devastating. Those movies have their place, but sometimes you just want to sit in a dark cinema and watch an ice-cream man unleash absolute carnage.

Ice Cream Man understands that.

It doesn’t ask you to take it seriously.

It asks you to enjoy the ride.

And if you do, you’ll probably have an absolute blast.

The film may not be the most sophisticated scoop in the freezer, but it is certainly one of the messiest — and most deliciously deranged.

★★★½ / 5

Leave a Reply
You May Also Like